Buying a Used Car vs New

Are you in the market for a car and wondering if you should buy a new one or used one? This is a choice people must make each day. We’re here to help you decide which option is best for your needs before you make your next big purchase.

Pros of Buying a Used Car

  • Less expensive: Used cars are typically more affordable than new ones. If you are wanting to save money on the initial purchase, monthly payments, and insurance, a used car could be the right choice for you.
  • Slower depreciation: Used cars depreciate much slower than new ones. In fact, new cars lose the most value when you drive them off the lot and during the first year of ownership. So, a car will have far less value lost during the first year you own it if it was owned before you.
  • Wider variety of models: There are most likely going to be more used cars to choose from in your budget rather than new ones. If you enjoy having the option to choose between many different styles, searching for a used car could be a great option for you.

Cons of Buying a Used Car

  • More maintenance repairs: Owning a car comes with maintenance repairs, but owning a used car might bring those repairs sooner. You should do your due diligence and see what information you can find on the vehicle. It could be helpful to find reports stating how often the previous owner did routine maintenance.
  • Compromises might be made: With a used car it can be challenging to find exactly what you want. You might be able to find a car that has majority of what you are wanting, but it most likely won’t have everything. Expect to make a few compromises when you shop for a car.
  • Car history: Unfortunately, you won’t know all the car’s history or the exact condition it is in. Consider having a trusted mechanic look at the car before you purchase it. This could help prevent you from making a large purchase and then having to spend more money on major repairs later.

Pros of Buying a New Car

  • Customization: This is one of the biggest reasons people like to buy a new car. You can choose everything you would like in a car, and you don’t have to settle for anything. You can even add on features to make it exactly what you would like.
  • More reliable: New cars are less likely to break down and need repairs. If they do need repairs during the first few years, they might be covered by a manufacturer’s warranty, helping you save money.
  • Lower financing: New cars typically have lower interest rates, helping you save some money. Check out our auto loan rates.

Cons of Buying a New Car

  • More expensive: When you’re searching for a vehicle, you will notice that new cars are typically several thousand dollars more than a used one. This will increase your down payment and even your monthly loan payments if you have a loan.
  • Depreciate faster: New cars unfortunately lose a lot of their value when they are driven off the lot. In fact, they depreciate the most during the first year and then slowly keep depreciating for several more years.
  • Higher insurance costs: You may have to pay more in insurance for a new car because they are worth more. They also might experience a higher chance of theft, resulting in a higher insurance payment.

Which Is Right for You?

Everyone has different needs, wants, and lifestyles. Choosing a car that is right for you can be a stressful decision but taking the points above into consideration can help relieve some of that stress.

Write down your wish list and budget before browsing the lots. Then you can decide which type of vehicle you want and start looking at what’s in stock near you.

In the end, you will know which option will work best for you. Consider all the pros and cons for both new and used cars. Enjoy your new ride!

You are now leaving Guardian Credit Union

You will be linking to another website not owned or operated by Guardian Credit Union. Guardian Credit Union is not responsible for the availability or content of this website and does not represent either the linked website or you, should you enter into a transaction. We encourage you to review their privacy and security policies which may differ from Guardian Credit Union.

You will be redirected to

Click the link above to continue or CANCEL